Tuesday, 2 August 2011

Both parties scheme for Ponzi cash

By Jim McElhatton - The Washington Post


The fundraising arms for Democratic and Republican members of Congress don’t agree on much, except when it comes to all the big donations they’ve gotten over the years from jailed financier R. Allen Stanford.

In recent days, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC), the National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC) and other party organizations appealed a court order to return more than $1.7 million combined they received that were tied to Mr. Stanford’s alleged multibillion-dollar bilking of thousands of investors. He’s in jail awaiting trial on charges of running a Ponzi scheme while a court-appointed receiver tries to recoup money for investors.

The appeals come a month after a federal judge in Texas ordered the organizations to return the money. But in a recent court filing, attorneys for the DSCC and the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, which owe more than $1.2 million combined, asked for a stay before having to turn over the money. They want to post bond or a letter of credit pending an appeal.

Meanwhile, in a separate set of court papers, attorneys for the NRCC, the Republican Senatorial Campaign Committee and Republican National Committee filed a notice to appeal the ruling, too.

“After thoroughly reviewing the court’s decision and the relevant law, and in light of an important change in the precedent on which the court relied, we believe we have an excellent chance of success,” said Kirsten Kukowski, spokeswoman for the RNC.

The combined legal efforts of the political parties show the lengths political committees mdash; Democrat and Republican alike — will go to protect party coffers with control of Congress and the White House up for grabs in 2012.

“Stanford aimed most of his campaign contributions to congressional leaders and party bosses, and eventually started giving heavily to presidential candidates as well, which coincided with the weakening of offshore disclosure and tax regulations that directly benefited Stanford’s shady business,” said Craig Holman, legislative representative for the D.C.-based watchdog group Public Citizen.

“Like other campaign contributions tainted by scandal, candidates and the party committees should try to show that they personally have not been influenced by the money and turn Stanford contributions over to charity,” he said.

Federal law allows campaign committees to part with donations in several ways. They can return contributions, donate them to charity or send the money to the U.S. Treasury.

But Ralph Janvey, receiver in the Stanford case, wants the money returned to investors. In addition to taking the major-party fundraising committees to court, the receiver previously sent letters to dozens of other politicians who received Stanford money over the years. More than a year later, he’s still waiting.

According to the most recent accounting last month, politicians have returned $132,500, with nearly $1.8 million still not yet returned, though most of that is still in the hands of the party fundraising groups fighting in court.

Aside from the political committees, Rep. Charles B. Rangel, New York Democrat, appears to be the biggest beneficiary of Stanford cash among those who have yet to return donations. The Rangel Victory Fund received $25,000 from Mr. Stanford, his associates and businesses, money that Mr. Janvey says is directly tied to the Ponzi scheme.

Other beneficiaries include the New Jersey Democratic State Committee and Rep. Pete Sessions, Texas Republican, with $10,000 each. Rep. Gregory Meeks, New York Democrat, received $6,600.

Phone and email messages left with the members of Congress were not returned, nor was a message left with the New Jersey Democratic State Committee.

Among dozens of politicians who have returned the contributions are Sen. Richard C. Shelby, Alabama Republican, who sent back $14,000; former Sen. Christopher J. Dodd, Connecticut Democrat, who returned $27,500 from his presidential and Senate campaigns; and Sen. Harry Reid, Nevada Democrat, who returned $8,000.

In court documents, attorneys for the major-party committees put forth several arguments for why they should be allowed to keep the contributions, including arguing that the lawsuits seeking the return of the money weren’t filed on time.

U.S. District Judge David Godbey disagreed, noting in a 61-page ruling that the committees “fail to create a fact issue concerning the Ponzi scheme’s existence or the contributions’ source and make no attempt to show that the contributions were made in exchange for consideration of reasonably equivalent value.”

The judge ordered the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee to return $1,037,347; the NRCC, $260,291; the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee, $218,273; the National Republican Senatorial Committee, $90,960; and the Republican National Committee, $140,241.

Kevin Sadler, attorney for Mr. Janvey, said in an email that the ruling represented an important victory for the receivership and thousands of victims of the Ponzi scheme.

“As important as this decision is, there remain hundreds of other defendants, individuals, companies and organizations, which, like these political committees, received hundreds of millions of dollars of investor funds diverted by Allen Stanford and his fraud scheme,” Mr. Sadler said.

“Such funds rightfully belong only to the receiver, whose duty it is to recover these funds and use them to compensate the victims of the Stanford fraud.”

Mr. Stanford’s trial recently was postponed from September to January. He has pleaded not guilty to charges of bilking investors of about $7 billion.

SEC Probing Stanford Receiver for Keeping $118 Million

By: Mary Thompson and Scott Cohn - CNBC

Investor complaints about the long delays and puny payouts from the receiver in charge of rounding up assets from Allen Stanford's alleged $7 billion ponzi scheme have prompted an SEC investigation of the receiver.

SEC Inspector General David Kotz confirms he is looking into whether the SEC's actions regarding oversight of the receiver has been on the up and up. In a motion filed Monday, attorneys said that of the $119.7 million recovered by the receiver, $118.2 million has gone to expenses and fees, leaving just $1.5 million for investors.

The receiver, Dallas attorney Ralph Janvey, was appointed by a federal judge at the SEC's request, after the agency sued Stanford in 2009. But more than two years later, Janvey has recovered just pennies on the dollar for Stanford investors.

"We did receive a complaint recently about Stanford receivership-related issue," Kotz told CNBC. "We have looked at it and plan to open up an inquiry or investigation with respect to allegations regarding improper conduct of SEC employees."

It is the latest in a series of Stanford-related investigations by Kotz, who earlier found SEC staffers were aware of problems at Stanford as far back as 1997.

The new investigation is apparently the result of a request by a Massachusetts law firm, Kachroo Legal Services, that has been attempting to intervene in the Stanford litigation on behalf of a handful of Stanford investors claiming "malfeasance and waste" in the receivership.

The complaint also alleges an improper relationship between Janvey and the official court-appointed Stanford investors committee, which consists of four attorneys and two individual investors. Rather than looking out for all 28,000 investors, the complaint alleges, the committee is simply generating more fees for the attorneys.

"And the potential compensation to these attorneys is enormous," the complaint says.

Janvey's attorney, Kevin Sadler, tells CNBC in a statement that Janvey has not yet heard from Kotz, "but will respond promptly and appropriately to any such request or inquiry, just as the receiver has responded to numerous requests from other government agencies" since being appointed in February of 2009.

"The allegation of an 'inside deal' between the receiver and the investors committee is patently false and completely irresponsible," the statement adds.

"Through dozens of motions, reports and fee applications filed with the court, as well as hearings held in open court, all of the receiver's activities have been transparent and open to scrutiny by the Court and other interested parties."

But attorney Gaytri Kachroo, who filed the new motion and requested the Inspector General's investigation, notes that the last time the SEC objected to a bill from Janvey was more than a year ago.

Stanford, 61, has denied wrongdoing and claims Janvey and the SEC have been dismantling a legitimate business. He is scheduled to go on trial in January on 14 criminal counts.

Thursday, 28 July 2011

Stanford International Bank Creditors’ Committee Urges U.S. and U.K. Authorities to Unfreeze Millions Immediately

Grant Thornton Press Release

Newly formed creditors’ committee is working closely with liquidators, but fears recovery efforts could stall if money isn’t released soon

ANTIGUA-July 13, 2011– Liquidators of Stanford International Bank announced today that its newly formed Advisory Creditors’ Committee is backing a proposal to urge the U.S. Department of Justice and the United Kingdom’s Serious Fraud Office to unfreeze critical funding to the estate immediately.

The Creditors’ Committee, which is currently made up of victims from six countries, says recovery efforts for over 21,000 creditors with $7.2 billion in claims will stall to the detriment of the estate unless money is released from the bank’s own accounts that have been frozen at the instigation of the DoJ for more than two years.
“The biggest single issue that we have facing us today is funding,” said Marcus Wide, who was appointed in May as liquidator of Stanford International Bank along with Hugh Dickson. “We have been in negotiations with the Department of Justice and Serious Fraud Office asking them to act quickly and release the money. At present we are optimistic as both DoJ and SFO have shown that they understand the nature of the difficulties facing our estate, and the potential impact on victims.Unfortunately the frozen assets have lost value while frozen and we fear they could continue to decline in value the longer they remain frozen. And more importantly the estate is presently without the money it needs to gather in and protect other assets to which the victims are entitled, and to fund the legal actions that can generate further recoveries for victims.”

“The Justice Department has frozen, at a cost to creditors, these funds which would otherwise have been handed over to the estate,” added Mr. Dickson. “It is the creditors’ money and it is unfortunate that it is not available to protect the creditors’ interests and generate additional recoveries in a situation which is otherwise rather bleak.” Approximately 99.7% of all 21,000 creditors of the Bank are holders of CDs that were victimized in R. Allen Stanford’s apparent fraud, according to the Liquidators.

The six-member Creditors’ Committee held its second meeting on July 7, 2011, and unanimously approved arrangements for alternate financing from commercial funders proposed by the Joint Liquidators urging the Antiguan Court to approve of that plan as well, so that the estate can do its job, although at greater cost to creditors, in the event that a portion of the frozen funds are not released. The High Court in Antigua has since approved the funding package in principle.

“This has been a trying time for all creditors and we have no time to lose in the recovery of our funds,” said Eric Cohen, a member of the Creditors’ Committee. “We all feel the sting of Stanford International Bank’s collapse, but we have faith in the approach Mr. Wide and Mr. Dickson are taking, and are pledging them our full support.”

Alexander Fundora, another member of the Creditors’ Committee and founder of a Miami, Fla.-based home health care company that lost $2.5 million in the Stanford scheme, said it is “hard to understand why the DoJ wants to retain control of our money and for it to expect the victims to absorb the expense of the commercial funding arrangements, when the bank’s own funds should be available at no cost. We urge the DoJ to release the funds immediately.”

Stanford International Bank failed in 2009 after top executives R. Allen Stanford, James M. Davis, and Laura Pendergest-Holt executed a massive Ponzi scheme misappropriating billions of dollars of investor funds, according to U.S. prosecutors.

Mr. Dickson and Mr. Wide, who are employed by Grant Thornton, a global audit, tax and advisory firm, were appointed liquidators on May 12, 2011, replacing Nigel Hamilton-Smith and Peter Wastell by order of the High Court of Antigua.

By creating a Creditors’ Committee, the new liquidators are working to have an ongoing dialogue with creditors and to create a creditor-driven estate, something that didn’t exist under the prior administration.

“We will consult with creditors in the early stages as often as we can,” Dickson said. “At the end of the day it is their money. It is important that we have access to the insights, opinions and support of the people who we serve.”

Members of the Creditors’ Committee include Mr. Fundora, United States; Mr. Cohen, Canada; Ricardo Del Valle, Panama; Luis Lopez, Venezuela; Attorney Patrick Kelly of Minneapolis (for a group of Mexican creditors who lost $66 million), and a Swiss member. A seventh creditor, Mr Richard Watson of Antigua has recently been invited from a number of applicants to join the Committee. The Committee will meet regularly and will weigh in on major decisions.

“We have gathered a group of knowledgeable individuals who are geographically diverse and represent both large and small creditors,” Mr. Wide said. “We are convinced that working with the creditors will expedite the process of recovering assets.”

.

Tuesday, 26 July 2011

SIPC Says It Need Not Reimburse Stanford Victims; SEC Disagrees

By John Sullivan, AdvisorOne

Dispute centers on meaning of 'theft' versus 'fraud.' SIPC to decide on next move by mid-September.

Call it splitting hairs, but at least one entity designed to protect investors from theft is sticking by its ruling against reimbursing the victims of money manager Allen Stanford. The key word is "theft," and Bloomberg reports the Securities Investor Protection Corp. (SIPC) alleges Stanford committed fraud, not theft, and therefore SIPC has no liability for damages.

Stanford, chairman of the now defunct Stanford Financial Group, based in Houston, was charged on Feb. 17, 2009 by the SEC with fraud and other violations of U.S. securities laws for an alleged $8 billion Pozi scheme that involved supposedly "safe" certificates of deposit.

SIPC maintains the circumstances specific to the Stanford case mean "that the law doesn’t provide for payouts to investors." The SEC’s staff initially agreed, but on June 15, the SEC informed SIPC that the “Stanford matter was appropriate for a proceeding under the Securities Investor Protection Act,” or SIPA.

The Bloomberg report says "the SEC told SIPC to start a process that could give as much as $500,000 to each qualified Stanford investor. The agency further surprised SIPC by threatening to sue if it didn’t carry out the plan."

SIPC said that said it expects its board to announce “on or about September 15, 2011 its decision about the referral from the SEC, and SIPC President and CEO Stephen Harbeck said that SIPC has “already started conferring with the SEC and the Stanford receiver regarding the SEC's referral in the Stanford matter.”

The SEC’s action “'is highly unusual,' SIPC’s Harbeck told the news service.

Bloomberg adds "Harbeck has said publicly that he doesn’t think the Stanford investors are eligible for repayments. SIPC is supposed to aid investors when their securities are stolen or go missing at a brokerage. Stanford’s customers still have possession of their securities, he said, and fraud by itself isn’t covered."

For people who lost money through the Stanford scheme, “it is very difficult to explain the difference between theft and fraud,” Harbeck said, according to Bloomberg.

Sunday, 24 July 2011

SEC Watchdog Probes Agency’s Oversight of Stanford Receiver

By Joshua Gallu - Bllomberg

The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission’s internal watchdog is investigating the agency’s dealings with the man hired to recover funds for victims of R. Allen Stanford’s alleged fraud amid claims the court-appointed receiver has taken too much money for himself.

Inspector General H. David Kotz said today he is reviewing the SEC’s oversight of the receiver, Ralph Janvey, after getting a complaint that the bulk of recovered funds has been used to cover legal bills.

Janvey was appointed in 2009 after the SEC sued Stanford and a federal grand jury indicted him on 21 criminal counts alleging that he used his Houston-based Stanford Financial Group and an Antigua-based banking unit to defraud clients through the sale of certificates of deposit. Stanford, who has denied the allegations, is being held without bail while awaiting trial.

Kachroo Legal Services P.C. of Cambridge, Massachusetts, released a statement yesterday accusing Janvey of “malfeasance and waste” in his management of collected assets and claiming there was an “inside deal” between Janvey and the Stanford investor committee to approve high fees.

Kevin Sadler, Janvey’s attorney, said that the allegations are “patently false and completely irresponsible.” Janvey, who hasn’t been contacted by Kotz, will respond “promptly and appropriately” to any request, Sadler said in a statement.

SEC spokesman Kevin Callahan declined to comment.

Stanford investors and lawmakers have pressed the SEC for more than two years demanding more help in recouping money lost in the alleged fraud. Last month, the SEC said some investors should be eligible for payouts from the Securities Investor Protection Corp., an industry-backed fund that protects customers when a brokerage fails.