Allen Stanford the Stanford Group Co. founder accused of leading a $7 billion investor-fraud scheme, can use corporate insurance policy proceeds to pay his defense lawyers, a judge ruled.
U.S. District Judge David Godbey of Dallas, who is hearing a Securities and Exchange Commission lawsuit against the Texas financier, ruled yesterday that he and other Stanford Group executives can draw from Lloyds of London officers’ and directors’ coverage said to be worth at least $50 million.
“The court finds it in the interest of fairness to allow directors and officers to access insurance proceeds to which they are entitled for several reasons,” Godbey said in a ruling posted to his court’s Web site that he said applies to all Stanford defendants. “The potential harm to them if denied coverage is not speculative but real and immediate; they may be unable to defend themselves in civil actions in which they do not have a right to court-appointed counsel.”
Stanford, who faces civil and criminal claims he swindled investors in a scheme involving the sale of certificates of deposit through Antigua-based Stanford International Bank Ltd., was given a federal public defender on Sept. 15 after a U.S. judge hearing his criminal case in Houston found he had no money to pay lawyers.
With a reported net worth of $2.2 billion, Stanford was ranked 205th on Forbes magazine’s 2008 list of richest Americans. He is being held without bail pending trial.
Kent Schaffer
Houston lawyer Kent Schaffer agreed to assist the public defenders’ office at the government pay rate of $110 an hour on Sept. 17. Stanford, who has denied all allegations of wrongdoing, has struggled to retain defense lawyers after his assets were frozen by the Dallas court on Feb. 17 following the filing of the SEC lawsuit.
The agency alleged that Stanford, two associates and three businesses paid early investors “improbable if not impossible” returns on their investments, using money received from later- arriving clients.
A U.S. grand jury in Houston in June indicted Stanford, his chief investment officer, Laura Pendergest-Holt, and three others for their alleged roles in the scheme. They all pleaded innocent. Stanford’s chief financial officer, James Davis, who was charged separately, pleaded guilty on Aug. 27 and is cooperating with the federal investigations.
DeGuerin, Luskin
Several high-priced lawyers have come and gone as Stanford’s attorney, including Houston criminal-defense lawyer Dick DeGuerin and Robert Luskin of Washington-based Patton Boggs.
DeGuerin withdrew in July after a dispute involving how he would be paid. Luskin was denied permission in August to represent Stanford for the limited purpose of helping the financier access money for lawyers.
Luskin, who said in an e-mail that he may continue helping Stanford appeal the denial of his bail, praised the ruling although he said he’s still digesting it.
“Obviously, we’re delighted with the ruling,” Luskin said. “It’s the right result and, much more important for Allen and for the justice system, helps to guarantee that Allen will have the resources to get a fair trial.”
Schaffer said in a phone interview yesterday that while he’s pleased with the ruling, he’s not sure how it will affect his ability to continue representing Stanford. Schaffer said the financier most likely doesn’t qualify for a publicly funded defense after the ruling, as taxpayers shouldn’t have to pay if Lloyd’s will.
‘Tremendous Progress’
“I’d like to stay on the case whether on an appointed or retained basis,” he said. “Now that we’ve been on the case for three weeks and we’ve done a ton of work, we think it’s a very defensible case. We’ve been making tremendous progress, and the further we get into it, the better the case is starting to look.”
Schaffer said he would meet with Stanford tomorrow at the federal prison in downtown Houston to learn whether the financier wants to keep him or change lawyers.
Ralph Janvey, the court-appointed receiver for Stanford’s businesses, had asked Godbey to reserve the Lloyd’s of London proceeds for his use in defending the Stanford companies against claims by investors and creditors.
Receivership Estate
The judge didn’t directly address Janvey’s request to reserve the policies for his use or declare the proceeds part of the receivership estate. Godbey called the receiver’s claim on the coverage “hypothetical” as Janvey hasn’t yet filed any invoices with the insurance carrier and Lloyd’s has filed a separate petition saying it plans to exclude Janvey as the receiver has repeatedly said the Stanford companies were involved in fraud.
“Those are questions for another day,” Godbey said in the ruling.
Kristie Blumenschein, Janvey’s spokeswoman, declined to comment on yesterday’s decision.
As many as 60 Stanford executives and employees are seeking to use the directors’ and officers’ coverage to defray their legal bills, according to Janvey. The receiver has said the coverage may be worth as much as $90 million.
Lawyers for Pendergest-Holt had asked the criminal case judge, David Hittner, to order Lloyd’s underwriters to pay the Stanford defendants’ legal bills.
Judge Hittner
While Hittner hasn’t ruled on Pendergest-Holt’s request, court filings indicate he made direct inquiries to both Janvey and Lloyd’s about whether anything prevented the insurer from paying the defendants’ legal bills. Both the receiver and Lloyds urged Hittner to defer to Godbey on the issue.
Pendergest-Holt’s lawyers said in e-mails yesterday that they are pleased with Godbey’s decision to let them access Stanford’s insurance coverage, a decision one said was “a long time coming.”
“We can now continue to concentrate our efforts on properly defending Ms. Holt without fear of financial ruin,” Dan Cogdell, Pendergest-Holt’s lead lawyer, wrote. “I have already re-submitted my prior bills to Lloyd’s. While I won’t say what the amount I am owed is, I will say it is a lot more than I am comfortable being owed.”
“There are many things to be done in connection with Ms. Holt’s defense that we as her lawyers have deferred due to lack of funds,” Jeffrey Tillotson, the Dallas lawyer assisting in Pendergest-Holt’s civil and criminal defense, said in a separate e-mail. “Ms. Holt hasn’t done anything wrong and has always intended on aggressively fighting the government’s charges. Now she will have some resources available to fight back.”
Cooperating Witness
David Finn, a lawyer for Davis, said the ruling will allow him to continue representing the government’s key cooperating witness.
“It means I will not have to file a motion to withdraw,” Finn said in an e-mail. “I am relieved because I will not have to keep digging into my pocket for expenses not knowing if I’d ever get paid.”
Welcome to the SIVG official Blog! (SIVG - Stanford International Victims Group http://sivg.org.ag)
Tuesday, 27 October 2009
Tuesday, 6 October 2009
Receiver Goes after Law Firms
Court-appointed receiver Ralph Janvey has turned the spotlight on two law firms. The Miami Herald reported over the weekend that Janvey, who has been working with federal agents, is now pressing for more information directly from Stanford's lawyers.
The receiver has made a request for legal files provided to R Allen Stanford by Greenberg Traurig and another firm, Hunton & Williams. The Herald listed this latest move by Janvey as “one of the most aggressive moves waged by the receiver to search for assets from Stanford's far-flung banking network".
While Greenberg Traurig is not under criminal investigation, the firm is facing a legal review of its actions in Antigua. Ross Gaffney, a former FBI agent who investigated Stanford, was quoted as saying: "I'm sure one of the things they will look at is what did Greenberg Traurig know, and when did they know it, and did they have any liability?''
According to the article, Greenberg Traurig's effort to assist Stanford in 1998 was but one move in a series which saw the Florida law firm rescuing Stanford from crisis and propelling his business interests. The Herald sought interviews with five lawyers who represented Stanford while working for the firm. Two of the five declined to comment, but assured that they were simply providing legal support and were not aware of any illegal schemes by Stanford.
The article spoke of a “money pipeline” between Miami and Antigua which Greenberg lawyers helped Stanford create. It went on to describe Stanford's creation of a trust office in downtown Miami which could move millions overseas without reporting anything to the government.
According to the article, “The unusual arrangement -- created over the objections of Florida's chief banking lawyer -- let Stanford open the office without submitting to fraud checks or money-laundering requirements. Over the next decade, the Miami center sold millions in Stanford's key investments -- certificates of deposit -- the checks stuffed in pouches and sent in jets to Antigua.”
The article also chronicled the changes in Antigua's banking system and Stanford's effort to “keep the pipeline alive”. The US Treasury, the article explained, was considering blacklisting all of Antigua's offshore institutions because of money laundering and fraud. In response, Stanford met with then prime minister, Lester Bird and agreed to pay out of his own pocket for a task force to rewrite the banking laws.
This task force, the article said, which included Greenberg lawyer Carlos Loumiet, met in Miami and St John's to examine ways to avoid a shutdown of the banks. According to the article, the 1998 legislation gave birth to a new regulatory agency - with Stanford on board - which would give protection to the investor from regulators for the next decade.
The Herald pointed to a particular incident which highlighted the power Stanford gained in Antigua by owning the largest bank. It spoke of the new regulatory agency requesting all of the island's secret offshore banking records. The head regulator, Althea Crick, refused. The agency waited until Crick had left for the day before seizing the filing cabinets containing the records and taking them to another building.
According to the story, the February 1999 takeover was approved by the new regulatory board, including an advisor to Bird, Errol Cort. The Herald rebutted statements which suggested that the takeover “was not done under the cover of darkness". According to the article, records show that Cort was a director of Stanford Trust Company and one of Stanford's Antigua lawyers.
International pressure from US and British authorities would later force Stanford to step down from his position and Antigua officials agreed to change the laws crafted by the task force. However, according to the article, “the momentum was in motion to help Stanford's bank for years to follow.”
It noted, “With the new regulatory agency enforcing new banking rules, most of the 56 offshore banks on the island were eliminated, swatting away much of his competition.” It also explained that court records show that Stanford's own bank was fabricating financial reports at the same time he was taking over the regulatory agency.
With millions of dollars coming into the Antiguan bank, Stanford switched to Hunton & Williams, after Loumiet joined the firm in 2001. In 2002, regulator Crick was replaced by Leroy King, who has been accused of taking more than $200,000 in bribes.
Loumiet and Hunton & Williams have agreed to turn over records of legal work for Stanford's US companies to Janvey. But they are fighting to keep secret the details of Stanford's businesses in Antigua and other foreign countries.
A spokeswoman for Hunton & Williams, Eleanor Kerlow, was quoted as saying: “There are legal issues regarding jurisdiction and client privilege that must be resolved before we proceed further.'”
According to the Herald, it is anticipated that Houston Judge David Godbey will decide whether the firm must meet Janvey's demands. Kristie Blumenschein, an attorney with the receiver's firm, has indicated that they are ready to fight for the records. According to Blumenschein, Janvey will not only search for assets, but the actions of the lawyers, dating to the 1990s, will also be under review.
It is being suggested that Janvey can demand lawyers be coerced into testifying about what they knew, since any conversations they had with Stanford about his ongoing crises are not protected by attorney-client privilege.
Comments (7)
...
written by MLM, October 05, 2009
Didn't Lester Bird give sanction to Stanford to rewrite the Banking Laws? which gave birth to a New Regulatory Agency, putting this whole thing in Motion. And we all know why that was done.
written by John, October 05, 2009
Errol should step down before the proverbial s--t hits the fan
Stanford Vindictive
written by RASCAS, October 05, 2009
This shows Standords vindictive nature. Get rid of al lthe other banks and he was the elephant in the ointment. Always the Expats. Antigua please learn, when we run our own affairs we don't end up in trouble. America was after their own. The ligimate banks get screwed in the crossfire. Go throught the history there is a glearing trend. Where is Bruce Rappaport?
is Cort inocent
written by yo mama, October 05, 2009
According to the story, the February 1999 takeover was approved by the new regulatory board, including an advisor to Bird, Errol Cort. The Herald rebutted statements which suggested that the takeover “was not done under the cover of darkness". According to the article, records show that Cort was a director of Stanford Trust Company and one of Stanford's Antigua lawyers.
OMG, Stanford , I am coming to join you Big Brother
written by 8 ball, October 05, 2009
Looks like Cort's day soon come.. Well he can use his National Security position and protect Stanford from the Prison inmate should they try to harm him again. Cant wait to see what he knows.
The receiver has made a request for legal files provided to R Allen Stanford by Greenberg Traurig and another firm, Hunton & Williams. The Herald listed this latest move by Janvey as “one of the most aggressive moves waged by the receiver to search for assets from Stanford's far-flung banking network".
While Greenberg Traurig is not under criminal investigation, the firm is facing a legal review of its actions in Antigua. Ross Gaffney, a former FBI agent who investigated Stanford, was quoted as saying: "I'm sure one of the things they will look at is what did Greenberg Traurig know, and when did they know it, and did they have any liability?''
According to the article, Greenberg Traurig's effort to assist Stanford in 1998 was but one move in a series which saw the Florida law firm rescuing Stanford from crisis and propelling his business interests. The Herald sought interviews with five lawyers who represented Stanford while working for the firm. Two of the five declined to comment, but assured that they were simply providing legal support and were not aware of any illegal schemes by Stanford.
The article spoke of a “money pipeline” between Miami and Antigua which Greenberg lawyers helped Stanford create. It went on to describe Stanford's creation of a trust office in downtown Miami which could move millions overseas without reporting anything to the government.
According to the article, “The unusual arrangement -- created over the objections of Florida's chief banking lawyer -- let Stanford open the office without submitting to fraud checks or money-laundering requirements. Over the next decade, the Miami center sold millions in Stanford's key investments -- certificates of deposit -- the checks stuffed in pouches and sent in jets to Antigua.”
The article also chronicled the changes in Antigua's banking system and Stanford's effort to “keep the pipeline alive”. The US Treasury, the article explained, was considering blacklisting all of Antigua's offshore institutions because of money laundering and fraud. In response, Stanford met with then prime minister, Lester Bird and agreed to pay out of his own pocket for a task force to rewrite the banking laws.
This task force, the article said, which included Greenberg lawyer Carlos Loumiet, met in Miami and St John's to examine ways to avoid a shutdown of the banks. According to the article, the 1998 legislation gave birth to a new regulatory agency - with Stanford on board - which would give protection to the investor from regulators for the next decade.
The Herald pointed to a particular incident which highlighted the power Stanford gained in Antigua by owning the largest bank. It spoke of the new regulatory agency requesting all of the island's secret offshore banking records. The head regulator, Althea Crick, refused. The agency waited until Crick had left for the day before seizing the filing cabinets containing the records and taking them to another building.
According to the story, the February 1999 takeover was approved by the new regulatory board, including an advisor to Bird, Errol Cort. The Herald rebutted statements which suggested that the takeover “was not done under the cover of darkness". According to the article, records show that Cort was a director of Stanford Trust Company and one of Stanford's Antigua lawyers.
International pressure from US and British authorities would later force Stanford to step down from his position and Antigua officials agreed to change the laws crafted by the task force. However, according to the article, “the momentum was in motion to help Stanford's bank for years to follow.”
It noted, “With the new regulatory agency enforcing new banking rules, most of the 56 offshore banks on the island were eliminated, swatting away much of his competition.” It also explained that court records show that Stanford's own bank was fabricating financial reports at the same time he was taking over the regulatory agency.
With millions of dollars coming into the Antiguan bank, Stanford switched to Hunton & Williams, after Loumiet joined the firm in 2001. In 2002, regulator Crick was replaced by Leroy King, who has been accused of taking more than $200,000 in bribes.
Loumiet and Hunton & Williams have agreed to turn over records of legal work for Stanford's US companies to Janvey. But they are fighting to keep secret the details of Stanford's businesses in Antigua and other foreign countries.
A spokeswoman for Hunton & Williams, Eleanor Kerlow, was quoted as saying: “There are legal issues regarding jurisdiction and client privilege that must be resolved before we proceed further.'”
According to the Herald, it is anticipated that Houston Judge David Godbey will decide whether the firm must meet Janvey's demands. Kristie Blumenschein, an attorney with the receiver's firm, has indicated that they are ready to fight for the records. According to Blumenschein, Janvey will not only search for assets, but the actions of the lawyers, dating to the 1990s, will also be under review.
It is being suggested that Janvey can demand lawyers be coerced into testifying about what they knew, since any conversations they had with Stanford about his ongoing crises are not protected by attorney-client privilege.
Comments (7)
...
written by MLM, October 05, 2009
Didn't Lester Bird give sanction to Stanford to rewrite the Banking Laws? which gave birth to a New Regulatory Agency, putting this whole thing in Motion. And we all know why that was done.
written by John, October 05, 2009
Errol should step down before the proverbial s--t hits the fan
Stanford Vindictive
written by RASCAS, October 05, 2009
This shows Standords vindictive nature. Get rid of al lthe other banks and he was the elephant in the ointment. Always the Expats. Antigua please learn, when we run our own affairs we don't end up in trouble. America was after their own. The ligimate banks get screwed in the crossfire. Go throught the history there is a glearing trend. Where is Bruce Rappaport?
is Cort inocent
written by yo mama, October 05, 2009
According to the story, the February 1999 takeover was approved by the new regulatory board, including an advisor to Bird, Errol Cort. The Herald rebutted statements which suggested that the takeover “was not done under the cover of darkness". According to the article, records show that Cort was a director of Stanford Trust Company and one of Stanford's Antigua lawyers.
OMG, Stanford , I am coming to join you Big Brother
written by 8 ball, October 05, 2009
Looks like Cort's day soon come.. Well he can use his National Security position and protect Stanford from the Prison inmate should they try to harm him again. Cant wait to see what he knows.
Saturday, 3 October 2009
Stanford Receiver Wants $8.8 Million More for Fees, Expenses
Ralph Janvey is asking for another $8.8 million in fees and expenses for his work as the court- appointed receiver for the businesses of accused Ponzi scheme mastermind R. Allen Stanford.
Janvey won court approval last month for about $20 million in fees and expenses for work he did from February through May on behalf of investors allegedly swindled out of more than $7 billion through a scheme involving Antiguan bank certificates of deposit. Yesterday’s request covers work by Janvey and 13 accounting and legal firms assisting him from June through August.
Janvey said the latest request reflects the 20 percent discount his team has applied to their standard billing rates throughout the Stanford Financial Group receivership assignment, out of consideration for how little money Stanford’s investors will likely recover. Of the $8.8 million he’s now requesting, Janvey said $2.2 million will be held back in accordance with a court ruling that he defer 20 percent of his billings until the ultimate success of his efforts can be assessed.
“Despite many unanticipated additional activities required of the professionals, these fees and expenses are less than what the receiver projected in the first and second interim fee applications,” Kevin Sadler, Janvey’s lead attorney, said in the filing.
Stanford, who is in jail awaiting trial on 21 felony counts that mirror allegations by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, denies any wrongdoing in connection with CDs sold by Stanford International Bank Ltd. in Antigua. The SEC accused him, some associates and three of his companies of running a “massive” fraud that paid early investors “improbable if not impossible” returns by taking funds from later investors.
Public Defender
Stanford, ranked as the 205th richest American in 2008 by Forbes magazine, with assets of $2 billion, was assigned a public defender after the judge in his criminal case concluded he had no money to pay attorneys. Stanford is fighting Janvey for access to his frozen assets or his company’s legal insurance policy so he can pay his own legal fees.
Kent Schaffer, Stanford’s court-appointed criminal-defense attorney, said Janvey’s fee request was “not surprising” in light of his earlier billings.
“It is sickening what they are doing and the rate at which they are looting the estate,” Schaffer said yesterday in an e-mail. He said Janvey should file a motion asking “that all assets recovered be conveyed to him” so his lawyers wouldn’t have to keep filing requests for additional fees.
Paid Nothing
Dan Cogdell, who represents Stanford’s chief investment officer and co-defendant Laura Pendergest-Holt, said it isn’t fair that Janvey has been paid millions in fees and expenses while the defendants’ lawyers haven’t been paid anything.
“I would feel a lot more sanguine about the situation if the receiver would not continue to be the impediment to our fees being paid,” Cogdell said in an e-mail message. “My firm began working on this matter in February, and we’ve not seen a single cent, due to the receiver’s objections to the insurer paying those fees.” John J. Little, the court-appointed examiner for Stanford’s investors in the SEC case, declined to comment on Janvey’s latest fee request.
“I haven’t had time to wade through the 1,000-plus pages” of supporting invoices and billing records Janvey submitted with his request, Little said in an e-mail. Previously, Little told the judge overseeing the case that he feared Janvey’s billings will consume the entire Stanford estate, leaving nothing for investors.
‘Something’ for Investors
That sentiment was echoed by David Finn, the attorney representing Stanford’s finance chief, James M. Davis, who pleaded guilty to the fraud and is cooperating with the government.
“I hope there’s something left for the investors,” Finn said in an e-mail response to Janvey’s filing.
Janvey won court approval last month for about $20 million in fees and expenses for work he did from February through May on behalf of investors allegedly swindled out of more than $7 billion through a scheme involving Antiguan bank certificates of deposit. Yesterday’s request covers work by Janvey and 13 accounting and legal firms assisting him from June through August.
Janvey said the latest request reflects the 20 percent discount his team has applied to their standard billing rates throughout the Stanford Financial Group receivership assignment, out of consideration for how little money Stanford’s investors will likely recover. Of the $8.8 million he’s now requesting, Janvey said $2.2 million will be held back in accordance with a court ruling that he defer 20 percent of his billings until the ultimate success of his efforts can be assessed.
“Despite many unanticipated additional activities required of the professionals, these fees and expenses are less than what the receiver projected in the first and second interim fee applications,” Kevin Sadler, Janvey’s lead attorney, said in the filing.
Stanford, who is in jail awaiting trial on 21 felony counts that mirror allegations by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission, denies any wrongdoing in connection with CDs sold by Stanford International Bank Ltd. in Antigua. The SEC accused him, some associates and three of his companies of running a “massive” fraud that paid early investors “improbable if not impossible” returns by taking funds from later investors.
Public Defender
Stanford, ranked as the 205th richest American in 2008 by Forbes magazine, with assets of $2 billion, was assigned a public defender after the judge in his criminal case concluded he had no money to pay attorneys. Stanford is fighting Janvey for access to his frozen assets or his company’s legal insurance policy so he can pay his own legal fees.
Kent Schaffer, Stanford’s court-appointed criminal-defense attorney, said Janvey’s fee request was “not surprising” in light of his earlier billings.
“It is sickening what they are doing and the rate at which they are looting the estate,” Schaffer said yesterday in an e-mail. He said Janvey should file a motion asking “that all assets recovered be conveyed to him” so his lawyers wouldn’t have to keep filing requests for additional fees.
Paid Nothing
Dan Cogdell, who represents Stanford’s chief investment officer and co-defendant Laura Pendergest-Holt, said it isn’t fair that Janvey has been paid millions in fees and expenses while the defendants’ lawyers haven’t been paid anything.
“I would feel a lot more sanguine about the situation if the receiver would not continue to be the impediment to our fees being paid,” Cogdell said in an e-mail message. “My firm began working on this matter in February, and we’ve not seen a single cent, due to the receiver’s objections to the insurer paying those fees.” John J. Little, the court-appointed examiner for Stanford’s investors in the SEC case, declined to comment on Janvey’s latest fee request.
“I haven’t had time to wade through the 1,000-plus pages” of supporting invoices and billing records Janvey submitted with his request, Little said in an e-mail. Previously, Little told the judge overseeing the case that he feared Janvey’s billings will consume the entire Stanford estate, leaving nothing for investors.
‘Something’ for Investors
That sentiment was echoed by David Finn, the attorney representing Stanford’s finance chief, James M. Davis, who pleaded guilty to the fraud and is cooperating with the government.
“I hope there’s something left for the investors,” Finn said in an e-mail response to Janvey’s filing.
Finra messed up, what a shock
The report by Finra on its failure to detect the alleged Ponzi scheme at Allen Stanford’s offshore bank is no shock.
Finra makes the SEC look like an agressive regulator. And this should give anyone reason to pause when you consider that Mary Schaprio, the current Securities and Exchange Commission chairman, most recently headed-up Finra.
Schaprio tells us her mission is to beef-up the SEC’s enforcement procedures in the wake of its own failings on Stanford and more significantly its botched investigation–or non-investigation–of Bernard Madoff. Why didn’t she first do this when she was at Finra?
The report outling Finra’s missteps notes regulators failed to follow-up on claims made by former Stanford brokers that the CDs the firm’s offshore bank in Antigua was selling were either bogus or “too good to be true.” Going as far back as 2004, a number of brokers raised this claim in arbitration disputes they had with Stanford.
Late last year, after Madoff was arrested, I began investigating allegations that Stanford’s financial empire was a Ponzi scheme. I did this while I was still working at BusinessWeek and early on I came across a few arbitration cases in which brokers had alleged the returns Stanford CDs seemed too good to be true.
Soon after Stanford was charged by the SEC with civil fraud, a source pointed me to an old lawsuit filed in Florida state court where a former employee also claimed the operation was a Ponzi scheme.
All of of these legal filings were either in the public record or in Finra files, yet it appears the level of communication between Finra’s arbitration unit and its enforcement operation is poor. This has been a long standing complaint from brokers, investors and securities lawyers and it needs to be fixed.
The inability of one side of an organization to talk to another can be damaging to a business. It’s no less damaging for a regulatory agency. But when regulators don’t communicate, innocent investors get hurt.
Finra makes the SEC look like an agressive regulator. And this should give anyone reason to pause when you consider that Mary Schaprio, the current Securities and Exchange Commission chairman, most recently headed-up Finra.
Schaprio tells us her mission is to beef-up the SEC’s enforcement procedures in the wake of its own failings on Stanford and more significantly its botched investigation–or non-investigation–of Bernard Madoff. Why didn’t she first do this when she was at Finra?
The report outling Finra’s missteps notes regulators failed to follow-up on claims made by former Stanford brokers that the CDs the firm’s offshore bank in Antigua was selling were either bogus or “too good to be true.” Going as far back as 2004, a number of brokers raised this claim in arbitration disputes they had with Stanford.
Late last year, after Madoff was arrested, I began investigating allegations that Stanford’s financial empire was a Ponzi scheme. I did this while I was still working at BusinessWeek and early on I came across a few arbitration cases in which brokers had alleged the returns Stanford CDs seemed too good to be true.
Soon after Stanford was charged by the SEC with civil fraud, a source pointed me to an old lawsuit filed in Florida state court where a former employee also claimed the operation was a Ponzi scheme.
All of of these legal filings were either in the public record or in Finra files, yet it appears the level of communication between Finra’s arbitration unit and its enforcement operation is poor. This has been a long standing complaint from brokers, investors and securities lawyers and it needs to be fixed.
The inability of one side of an organization to talk to another can be damaging to a business. It’s no less damaging for a regulatory agency. But when regulators don’t communicate, innocent investors get hurt.
Friday, 2 October 2009
Finra Missed Chances to Catch Stanford and Madoff, Report Says
The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority didn’t fully probe transactions at Bernard Madoff’s firm and repeatedly failed to investigate tips about R. Allen Stanford’s alleged $7 billion fraud, an internal report said.
The staff of the U.S. brokerage industry’s main regulator is “not adequately trained” on its investigative authority, and the Washington-based regulator lacks procedures to escalate matters to senior management or special investigators “based on the gravity and substance of the fraud allegations,” according to a report posted on Finra’s Web site today.
The findings follow a series of reports by Securities and Exchange Commission Inspector General H. David Kotz, which faulted the SEC’s oversight of Madoff over 16 years and examined the agency’s attempts to investigate Stanford. In the Stanford case, Kotz concluded that the SEC was hampered by jurisdictional limits and Stanford’s refusal to cooperate.
“As regulators, we owe it to investors -- especially those harmed by recent scandals -- to develop a better, more comprehensive, response to fraud,” Finra Chief Executive Officer Richard Ketchum said in a statement. “I am committed to taking the lessons from the report’s findings to make Finra even stronger.”
Finra said it will create a new Office of Fraud Detection and Market Intelligence to ensure that staff with expertise in fraud detection respond rapidly to suspected scams.
The staff of the U.S. brokerage industry’s main regulator is “not adequately trained” on its investigative authority, and the Washington-based regulator lacks procedures to escalate matters to senior management or special investigators “based on the gravity and substance of the fraud allegations,” according to a report posted on Finra’s Web site today.
The findings follow a series of reports by Securities and Exchange Commission Inspector General H. David Kotz, which faulted the SEC’s oversight of Madoff over 16 years and examined the agency’s attempts to investigate Stanford. In the Stanford case, Kotz concluded that the SEC was hampered by jurisdictional limits and Stanford’s refusal to cooperate.
“As regulators, we owe it to investors -- especially those harmed by recent scandals -- to develop a better, more comprehensive, response to fraud,” Finra Chief Executive Officer Richard Ketchum said in a statement. “I am committed to taking the lessons from the report’s findings to make Finra even stronger.”
Finra said it will create a new Office of Fraud Detection and Market Intelligence to ensure that staff with expertise in fraud detection respond rapidly to suspected scams.