Thursday, 10 October 2013

Victims of Stanford Ponzi scheme fear they’ve been burned again


Ralph Janvey, the receiver in the Stanford case, has mailed checks from $2.81 to $110,000 to investors -- less than a penny of return on the dollar.

 By LAUREN KYGER 
 Center for Public Integrity 
 Published: 10 October 2013 05:01 AM 
 Updated: 10 October 2013 07:14 AM 

 When 18,000 people got fleeced in R. Allen Stanford’s $7.2 billion Ponzi scheme, the court appointed a receiver in 2009 to recover as much money as possible from Stanford’s failed companies to return to investors.

 After 41/2 years, the receiver, Ralph Janvey, began mailing checks ranging from $2.81 to $110,000 to hundreds of investors. That amounts to about $55 million of the $6 billion lost in the scheme, less than a penny on the dollar.

 Unlike the investors, Janvey, who has billed from $340 to $400 an hour for his services, is making out quite well. To date, Janvey and his team have recovered $234.9 million from the bankrupt Stanford Financial Group and spent more than half the total — about $124 million — on personnel and other expenses.

 “From the victims’ point of view, there is no way, shape or form that the receivership could be viewed as successful, this has been one of the biggest failures of a liquidation in history".

” The largest chunk of the Janvey team’s expenses — $67.1 million — was spent on “receivership’s professional fees and expenses,” according to court documents. Those fees and expenses add up to more than 28.5 percent of the money recovered from Stanford’s assets so far.

 Janvey has “complete and exclusive control, possession, and custody” of the assets left behind by Stanford’s business, according to the court order that named him receiver on Feb. 17, 2009.

 Janvey’s attorney, Kevin Sadler of Houston law firm Baker Botts, said the high costs are an unfortunate downside of unwinding R. Allen Stanford’s 18-year financial house of cards, which had offices in 23 states and 13 countries and more than 3,000 employees.

Worldwide tug of war 

 Sadler said Janvey has been fighting a “worldwide tug of war over what was left of Stanford’s assets,” involving multiple national governments and liquidators in Antigua, where Stanford International Bank was located. In March, Janvey reached a settlement to recover about $300 million of Stanford’s assets that have been frozen in Switzerland, Canada and the United Kingdom.

 Sadler said such lawsuits are now the best hope for getting more money back for Stanford’s victims.

 Janvey has been enmeshed in controversy regarding the Stanford liquidation. The Securities and Exchange Commission, which nominated Janvey and rarely has public disputes with receivers, won a motion to rein in some of his spending in June 2009 after the first fee applications were submitted.

 The expenses included a $160,000 payment to a public relations firm called Pierpont Communications for three months of reviewing, sorting and forwarding emails in 2009. In a written objection to the fee application, court-appointed examiner John Little said he had “significant doubt that Pierpont has created any benefit for the receivership estate.”

 $9,439 a day 

 FTI Consulting, a forensic accounting firm, billed more than $528,000 in airfare, parking, hotels, taxis and subway costs to the estate for its first 56 days on the job. Little objected, pointing out that this amounted to “$9,439 in travel-related expenses per day, every day, during the first 56 days.”

 A large part of the receivership’s early spending — $48 million — went to winding down the more than 100 companies in the Stanford Group, costs that were unavoidable, Sadler says.

 Today, Little says, Janvey’s spending has slowed. In the 12 months ending June 30, he’s spent $9.1 million, compared with $20 million spent in the first two months of the receivership in 2009.

 U.S. District Judge David C. Godbey denied a 2011 request by unhappy investors to intervene in the case because they believed Janvey was spending too much. Godbey noted that “the rate of expenditures on professional fees has decreased markedly over time, with the bulk of such expenses incurred relatively early in the receivership.”

 When large Ponzi schemes or companies go bankrupt, court-appointed receivers often find themselves employed for long stretches with a guaranteed income. There are no clear rules or guidelines dictating how a receiver should go about unwinding a failed or fraudulent business or recovering its assets, Sadler said.

 That allows receivers like Janvey to work full time for years on an estate, billing either investors or the congressionally chartered Securities Investor Protection Corp., or SIPC.

 R. Allen Stanford’s $7 billion scam was just one of many Ponzi schemes to fall apart within the past five years. Most notably, Bernard Madoff was sentenced to 150 years in prison for operating a $50 billion Ponzi scheme that cost investors more than $17 billion.

 Irving Picard, the Madoff receiver who was appointed in December 2008, says he has spent about $850 million trying to recover money for investors. The number is huge, but it’s less than 10 percent of the $9.5 billion he has returned to Madoff’s victims. He’s distributed $4.9 billion.

 He declined to say whether he believes Janvey’s costs are too high.

 “I don’t know enough about the specifics about what he had to do,” Picard said.

 Sadler said Madoff’s scheme was a “compact operation to wind down” compared with Stanford’s, which involved more than 100 interconnected companies.

 Like Picard, he said, Janvey watches his costs.

 “We’ve been pretty sensitive to the fact that we can’t spend $10 to recover $10 — or even $5,” he said. 

Janvey has sued about 1,800 former Stanford employees and customers who he says got money from the company, either in salary, bonuses or investment returns, that rightfully belongs to the defrauded investors. 

“Everyone we have sued, we have sued because in both fact and law we believe they received money they were not entitled to,” Sadler said.

 He said the total amount that Janvey could recover from these lawsuits is $1 billion, the only remaining source of money for the defrauded investors. Most of the former employees and clients are fighting the suits because they believe they only got money they were entitled to.

Political parties sued

 Janvey has sued thousands of people, but he has forgone many lawsuits because the return wasn’t worth it. For example, Janvey sued the Democratic and Republican national party committees to recover Stanford’s contributions. He also sent letters to the more than 50 senators and House members who received Stanford contributions but did not go to court.

 Fewer than 20 returned the money, he said.

 Janvey has been widely criticized for spending too much, but Sadler insists it’s the only way to resolve a major fraud.

 “When these things collapse, they just cost a lot of money to clean up,” he said.

 The Center for Public Integrity is a nonprofit, independent investigative news outlet. For more of its stories on this topic, go to publicintegrity.org.

 $7.2 billion - Amount bilked from investors by R. Allen Stanford’s Ponzi scheme
 $234.9 million - Amount recovered from the bankrupt Stanford Financial Group
 $124 million - Amount spent by the receiver on personnel and other expenses
 $55 million - Amount returned to investors so far


 For a full and open debate on the Stanford Receivership visit the Stanford International Victims Group - SIVG official forum http://sivg.org.ag/

Monday, 7 October 2013

SLUSA – decision being heard today!!

Stanford Ponzi Scheme Opens Supreme Court Term 

Dispute Over Whether Law and Insurance Firms Can Be Sued Is Among Spate of Business Cases on Docket.

 By BRENT KENDALLCONNECT

Victims of his Ponzi scheme want to be able to sue third parties.

When Supreme Court justices return to the bench Monday after a three-month summer break, R. Allen Stanford's $7 billion Ponzi scheme will await them.

 The court will hear oral arguments on the first day of its 2013-14 term to decide whether Mr. Stanford's victims should be allowed to sue third parties such as law firms and insurance brokers on allegations that they aided Mr. Stanford's scheme.

 Advocates for the defendants warn that allowing such lawsuits could compromise congressional efforts to curb unwarranted litigation that affects securities markets.

 Supporters of Mr. Stanford's victims say Congress never intended to shield wrongdoers in cases where people were tricked into investing in bogus private offerings.

 The case is among more than two dozen on the court's docket that could have implications for businesses. "These aren't the sexiest cases but they're incredibly important," says Thomas C. Goldstein of Goldstein & Russell PC, a veteran attorney before the high court who will argue for victims of the Stanford Ponzi scheme.
Mr. Stanford, once known for his jets, yachts and passion for cricket, was convicted last year and sentenced to 110 years in prison. U.S. authorities said the financier bilked investors by selling them certificates of deposit that he falsely claimed were backed by safe investments. Instead, he used new sales of CDs to pay other investors while funneling money into risky real-estate assets and his own businesses, prosecutors said.

 Investors now are going after law and financial-services firms with ties to Mr. Stanford's operations. Victims allege in class-action lawsuits filed under Louisiana and Texas laws that SEI Investments Co. SEIC -1.14%and insurance brokers, including subsidiaries of Willis Group Holdings misrepresented the CDs as safe investments. The plaintiffs also allege that law firms Proskauer Rose LLP and Chadbourne & Parke LLP knowingly helped Mr. Stanford's Antigua-based bank evade regulatory oversight.

 The defendants say that defrauded investors are targeting deep-pocketed third parties with remote connections to the Stanford enterprise because Mr. Stanford and his companies are insolvent.

Pennsylvania-based SEI declines to comment beyond its court papers, which say it merely provided a Stanford affiliate with back-office services. Willis Group says in briefs that it helped Mr. Stanford's bank purchase ordinary insurance policies. A spokeswoman says the company looks forward to the Supreme Court's review.

 The law firms say in briefs that they didn't make misrepresentations to investors, calling the suits baseless. Representatives for the law firms didn't respond to requests for comment.

 The defendants will be represented Monday by prominent Supreme Court lawyer Paul Clement of Bancroft PLLC, who will argue that the lawsuits are barred under the 1998 federal Securities Litigation Uniform Standards Act, which largely prohibits state-law class-action claims for securities fraud.

 Mr. Clement says in briefs that Congress was concerned about abusive litigation and wrote the law broadly to stop "enterprising lawyers" from using state law to evade federal limits imposed by Congress and the Supreme Court.

 The defendants received a boost from the Obama administration, which filed a brief, signed by the Securities and Exchange Commission, urging the Supreme Court to rule against the investor suits in Chadbourne & Parke v. Troice.

 The Fifth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled last year that the cases against the third parties could move forward. The appellate court, which is based in New Orleans, held that the fraudulent CDs weren't securities traded on national markets, meaning that the federal restrictions on securities-fraud lawsuits didn't apply in the same way.

 "We don't think Congress wanted to snuff out really the only effective remedy for fraud in these state-regulated CDs," says Mr. Goldstein, the plaintiffs' lawyer.


Read More: http://sivg.org.ag/topic203.html 

 For a full and open debate on the Stanford Receivership visit the Stanford International Victims Group - SIVG official forum http://sivg.org.ag/



Saturday, 5 October 2013

Receiver files 3rd Schedule of Payments to be Made Pursuant to the Interim Distribution Plan

On October 4, 2013, the Receiver filed his 3rd Schedule of distribution payments with the United States District Court for the Northern District of Texas, Dallas Division. The 3rd Schedule will be followed by others, each of which will be submitted by the Receiver on a rolling basis as additional responses to Certification Notices are received and processed.

 To view a copy of the 3rd Schedule, please click here:

http://sivg.org.ag/topic200.html


For a full and open debate on the Stanford Receivership visit the Stanford International Victims Group - SIVG official forum http://sivg.org.ag/

Thursday, 3 October 2013

For those who missed the original Claims Deadline

I have had several victims - who for whatever reason missed the registration deadline last September and have asked me what they need to do to get their claim registered now. I have been speaking to Baker Botts and this is the reply he has sent to me:

 "Generally, if a claimant failed to file a claim with the US receivership prior to the September 1, 2012 bar date, such claims are forever barred as against the US receivership estate, per order of the Court. If there are extenuating circumstances that constitute good cause, the Receivership will consider the circumstances and make a determination whether to recommend acceptance of the late claims by the Court. Given the notice provided, however, we expect that good cause will be a difficult threshold to meet. If claimants wish to submit requests to accept late claims to the receivership, they can use the contact information below.

 Nonetheless, claimants who filed claims with the Joint Liquidators prior to September 1, 2012 but did not file with the U.S. receivership by that date may be allowed to participate in future receivership distributions if the Receiver determines the claimant has a valid claim and the claimant agrees to jurisdiction of the US Court. We will communicate directly with claimants who filed with the Joint Liquidators before the US receivership bar date with the appropriate form(s) to execute for the purpose of ensuring that such claimants agree to the jurisdiction of the U.S. District Court in Texas. Only after we have done so and received the appropriate forms back from the claimants will notices of determination issue to those claimants. Even if such claimants are allowed to participate in future distributions from the receivership, they will not be eligible to participate in the current distribution that has already been approved by the Court. 


Regards," 


 It would appear that if you missed filing your claim with Janvey (Gilardi), you are now bared from registering - except for special circumstances as above. I do feel sorry for all those who have missed out and I am sorry to have to be the bearer of such bad news. Let's hope you have all registered with Grant Thornton. Sadly I cannot help those of you who missed last Septembers deadline with Janvey.

 Read More: http://sivg.org.ag/topic199.html 

 For a full and open debate on the Stanford Receivership visit the Stanford International Victims Group - SIVG official forum http://sivg.org.ag/


Wednesday, 2 October 2013

The final decision

Stanford Group sold the CDs while claiming that they were backed, at least in part, by SLUSA-covered securities.

 Therefore, the government's lawyers say, the bogus investments were in fact sold "in connection with" covered securities. And for SLUSA to work, it must be interpreted broadly, and the SEC's views (as the SLUSA watchdog) must be given deference.

 "Congress intended the phrase 'in connection with' to sweep widely enough to ensure achievement of 'a high standard of business ethics in the securities industry,'" while reining in excessive class actions, the government argues.

 But Preis says the SEC is backing what Goldstein calls a "newfound interpretation of the securities laws" to broaden its enforcement power "at the expense of backing the Stanford victims." Since the Stanford products that local investors bought were not sold on the New York Stock Exchange, state law should apply, he says.

 Regardless, it's an intriguing turn in the SEC's complicated role in the Stanford fiasco. Many victims blame the regulators for not catching on to Allen Stanford's scheme early. But the SEC backed investors' controversial bid for relief from the Securities Investor Protection Corp., even though the Stanford International Bank in Antigua, which issued the worthless CDs, was never a SIPC member.

 Read More: http://sivg.org.ag/topic198.html 

 For a full and open debate on the Stanford Receivership visit the Stanford International Victims Group - SIVG official forum http://sivg.org.ag/