Jailed former billionaire R. Allen Stanford has had trouble paying, and thus keeping, his attorneys, and now it appears two of them got into a physical altercation last month.
A Houston Police Department report shows that on the evening of July 10 several officers responded to a call to the office of Dick DeGuerin, a criminal defense lawyer who has since asked to be released from representing Stanford.
DeGuerin said he called police because Houston attorney Michael Sydow punched him and was trespassing and refused to leave.
But Sydow, a civil lawyer who has attempted to serve in limited capacity in Stanford's criminal case, told police that DeGuerin pushed him into a chair and bumped him with his chest.
Houston Police spokesman John Cannon confirmed that the report includes a photo of DeGuerin's chest with a red mark where DeGuerin said Sydow punched him with his fist.
Neither lawyer pressed charges.
DeGuerin said the two argued over a written statement in which Stanford allowed DeGuerin to collect his fees from an insurance policy Stanford's company carried. Exactly how Stanford will pay whoever ends up representing him is unclear, because his assets were frozen when federal regulators filed a civil fraud complaint against him, his companies, and other company executives.
DeGuerin said Sydow called him a liar. He said he then ordered Sydow out of the office and grabbed the document, at which point Sydow punched him. DeGuerin, who had a knee replacement a month before the incident, said he neither pushed nor chest bumped Sydow. He said two other men from the office intervened and corralled Sydow into an outer office while DeGuerin called police.
Sydow, who said he is serving as local counsel in the criminal case, said Friday that they were discussing DeGuerin charging a $30 million flat fee to Stanford.
Sydow said he told DeGuerin he thought it unethical to change fees mid-representation, and that riled DeGuerin.
Sydow said he stood up and DeGuerin shoved him back into a chair, grabbed the document and then claimed Sydow assaulted DeGuerin. Sydow said he never punched DeGuerin.
DeGuerin said details of this altercation are among many papers he's supplied Senior U.S. Judge David Hittner in his effort to get off the case. He said the documents show that Stanford wishes to have other attorneys, including Sydow. DeGuerin said he can't work with Sydow.
Stanford faces 21 criminal charges in an alleged $7 billion scam focusing on CDs at his offshore bank.
On July 31, a news release announced Stanford's new criminal lawyer would be Robert Luskin of Washington, D.C.
Luskin said he would enter the case only if he could be assured he would be paid.
Hittner refused to release DeGuerin from the case until another lawyer entered unconditionally.
Hittner denied Sydow's request to enter the case just to receive notices regarding whether Luskin could be paid. Luskin and Sydow went to an appeals court to remove Judge Hittner from the case but were denied.
“It's an impossible situation,” DeGuerin said.
Welcome to the SIVG official Blog! (SIVG - Stanford International Victims Group http://sivg.org.ag)
Saturday, 22 August 2009
Wednesday, 19 August 2009
Appellate court: Stanford criminal case stays put
An appellate court today refused to move R. Allen Stanford's criminal case to a new federal judge as the fallen billionaire requested.
A three-member panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals denied the request in a one-sentence order.
Houston civil attorney Michael Sydow and Washington criminal defense lawyer Robert Luskin had asked that Senior U.S. District Judge David Hittner be removed from the case and it be moved to U.S. District Judge Vanessa Gilmore, who drew the first case against one of Stanford's codefendants. Stanford and others are accused of bilking investors in a $7 billion fraud.
“We're disappointed in the result but hopeful that Mr. Stanford will ultimately be permitted to be represented by counsel of his choice,” Luskin said Tuesday.
Luskin and Sydow argued Hittner exhibited “unexplained hostility” in refusing Sydow's request to make an appearance and in ordering that Sydow have no further involvement in the criminal case.
Sydow asked the court to consider him Stanford's lawyer for the limited purpose of receiving notices on a motion filed by Luskin's firm, Patton Boggs, which wants assurance it will be paid before it agrees to represent Stanford.
Houston criminal defense lawyer Dick DeGuerin has asked to be released from the case but Hittner has required DeGuerin stay on until another lawyer enters unconditionally on Stanford's behalf.
Today's appellate ruling came just hours after prosecutors Gregg Costa and Paul Pelletier asked the court to deny Stanford's request to move the case. They said the request for appellate intervention was premature and that allowing attorneys into the case conditionally would cause delay.
The prosecutors said Hittner did not display bias against Sydow and that the matter of fees could be resolved in other courts.
Stanford has not been able to pay his lawyers because his personal assets were frozen along with his company's assets in a civil suit filed in Dallas by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Attorneys for several Stanford-related entities and individuals are attempting to be paid through unfrozen assets or an insurance policy.
A three-member panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals denied the request in a one-sentence order.
Houston civil attorney Michael Sydow and Washington criminal defense lawyer Robert Luskin had asked that Senior U.S. District Judge David Hittner be removed from the case and it be moved to U.S. District Judge Vanessa Gilmore, who drew the first case against one of Stanford's codefendants. Stanford and others are accused of bilking investors in a $7 billion fraud.
“We're disappointed in the result but hopeful that Mr. Stanford will ultimately be permitted to be represented by counsel of his choice,” Luskin said Tuesday.
Luskin and Sydow argued Hittner exhibited “unexplained hostility” in refusing Sydow's request to make an appearance and in ordering that Sydow have no further involvement in the criminal case.
Sydow asked the court to consider him Stanford's lawyer for the limited purpose of receiving notices on a motion filed by Luskin's firm, Patton Boggs, which wants assurance it will be paid before it agrees to represent Stanford.
Houston criminal defense lawyer Dick DeGuerin has asked to be released from the case but Hittner has required DeGuerin stay on until another lawyer enters unconditionally on Stanford's behalf.
Today's appellate ruling came just hours after prosecutors Gregg Costa and Paul Pelletier asked the court to deny Stanford's request to move the case. They said the request for appellate intervention was premature and that allowing attorneys into the case conditionally would cause delay.
The prosecutors said Hittner did not display bias against Sydow and that the matter of fees could be resolved in other courts.
Stanford has not been able to pay his lawyers because his personal assets were frozen along with his company's assets in a civil suit filed in Dallas by the Securities and Exchange Commission. Attorneys for several Stanford-related entities and individuals are attempting to be paid through unfrozen assets or an insurance policy.
Monday, 17 August 2009
Stanford Regulators Admit Not Pursuing '03 Fraud Claim
The industry self-regulatory organization that was supposed to police the brokers at the Stanford Financial Group acknowledges that a Stanford employee alleged in 2003 that the company was running a Ponzi scheme, but the organization did not follow up on the claim based of its own policy, which has since been changed.
The disclosure comes in testimony from Daniel Sibears, Executive Vice President of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, FINRA, prepared for a Senate Banking Committee hearing on Monday.
In 2003, Stanford advisor Leyla Wydler alleged in an arbitration case that the company was "engaged in a Ponzi scheme to defraud its clients."
Wydler lost the arbitration case, and FINRA is now acknowledging that her allegations of fraud were never passed on to investigators by the FINRA arbitration panel. Sibears' testimony said that prior to this year, FINRA procedure was to review fraud claims in arbitrations involving customers, but not those that involved employment disputes like Leyla Wydler's.
"This was based on an assessment that customer claims were most likely to evidence misconduct leading to investor harm," the testimony says.
Sibears insists in the testimony that "FINRA reviews every customer complaint and regulatory tip it receives." Nontheless, he acknowledged, the procedure involving employment disputes was changed in March of this year. The change came less than a month after the Securities and Exchange Commission sued Stanford, alleging an $8 billion Ponzi scheme.
Sibears' testimony claimed that even if the agency had followed up on Wydler's allegations, it likely would have run into barriers from regulators in Antigua, home of Stanford's offshore bank, where he says officials were less than cooperative in investigating subsequent tips.
After she lost the arbitration in 2004, Wydler brought her concerns to the Securities and Exchange Commission, which launched a formal investigation the following year. But the SEC did not sue Stanford until this year. The agency says it, too, was thwarted by Antiguan regulators, and added the nation's chief financial regulator to its complaint in June.
Hundreds of people attended the Banking Committee hearing, which was held in Baton Rouge, LA, home to a large concentration of Stanford investors. They have complained that regulators were slow to catch the alleged fraud, which affected some 28,000 investors.
The disclosure comes in testimony from Daniel Sibears, Executive Vice President of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority, FINRA, prepared for a Senate Banking Committee hearing on Monday.
In 2003, Stanford advisor Leyla Wydler alleged in an arbitration case that the company was "engaged in a Ponzi scheme to defraud its clients."
Wydler lost the arbitration case, and FINRA is now acknowledging that her allegations of fraud were never passed on to investigators by the FINRA arbitration panel. Sibears' testimony said that prior to this year, FINRA procedure was to review fraud claims in arbitrations involving customers, but not those that involved employment disputes like Leyla Wydler's.
"This was based on an assessment that customer claims were most likely to evidence misconduct leading to investor harm," the testimony says.
Sibears insists in the testimony that "FINRA reviews every customer complaint and regulatory tip it receives." Nontheless, he acknowledged, the procedure involving employment disputes was changed in March of this year. The change came less than a month after the Securities and Exchange Commission sued Stanford, alleging an $8 billion Ponzi scheme.
Sibears' testimony claimed that even if the agency had followed up on Wydler's allegations, it likely would have run into barriers from regulators in Antigua, home of Stanford's offshore bank, where he says officials were less than cooperative in investigating subsequent tips.
After she lost the arbitration in 2004, Wydler brought her concerns to the Securities and Exchange Commission, which launched a formal investigation the following year. But the SEC did not sue Stanford until this year. The agency says it, too, was thwarted by Antiguan regulators, and added the nation's chief financial regulator to its complaint in June.
Hundreds of people attended the Banking Committee hearing, which was held in Baton Rouge, LA, home to a large concentration of Stanford investors. They have complained that regulators were slow to catch the alleged fraud, which affected some 28,000 investors.
Sunday, 16 August 2009
Who is Ralph Janvey? Stanford's victims know he wants a third
Sir Allen Stanford's attorney doesn't like Ralph Janvey, but that's not surprising. The SEC isn't crazy about him either, and U.S. Judge David Godbey told him, "You know everyone in the courtroom is angry with you," according to a report in USA Today.
Janvey has been tasked with taking over and cleaning up the wreckage from Stanford's $7 billion Ponzi scheme -- the second largest known disaster of this kind. Along the way, he's managed to piss off everyone he's encountered. The latest "transgression" is his demand for more than $27 million in fees for his team and the consultants he's hired to track down the missing billions of dollars in Stanford's former empire.
More than 20,000 investors are waiting in line for their respective pounds of flesh. And now, they have to wait in line behind the lawyer.
The full request, which hasn't been ruled on yet, consists of $20 million for which Janvey asked in mid-May, covers his team's work through April 12, with another $7.6 million covering the seven weeks that followed.
And, he wants much more ... a third, actually.
Janvey's team stretches to more than 100, and he's asking for 34% of the $81.1 million on hand to compensate these guys. The investors, of course, would walk away with a fraction of their lost money. The SEC is pushing back on the bill, which includes $8.9 million for advisory firm FTI Consulting and $8.4 million for law firm Baker Botts (interesting note: I did a jury duty stint where Baker Botts was defense council ... hopefully it will do better this time).
The SEC objects to $500 an hour rates for FTI ... and $280 an hour to make copies. But, what's the big deal? Digging through and sorting out fraud is not easy. The discounts that clients can usually squeeze out of consultants and attorneys are harder to come by. So, even the 20% discount Janvey's offered doesn't amount to much
Janvey has been tasked with taking over and cleaning up the wreckage from Stanford's $7 billion Ponzi scheme -- the second largest known disaster of this kind. Along the way, he's managed to piss off everyone he's encountered. The latest "transgression" is his demand for more than $27 million in fees for his team and the consultants he's hired to track down the missing billions of dollars in Stanford's former empire.
More than 20,000 investors are waiting in line for their respective pounds of flesh. And now, they have to wait in line behind the lawyer.
The full request, which hasn't been ruled on yet, consists of $20 million for which Janvey asked in mid-May, covers his team's work through April 12, with another $7.6 million covering the seven weeks that followed.
And, he wants much more ... a third, actually.
Janvey's team stretches to more than 100, and he's asking for 34% of the $81.1 million on hand to compensate these guys. The investors, of course, would walk away with a fraction of their lost money. The SEC is pushing back on the bill, which includes $8.9 million for advisory firm FTI Consulting and $8.4 million for law firm Baker Botts (interesting note: I did a jury duty stint where Baker Botts was defense council ... hopefully it will do better this time).
The SEC objects to $500 an hour rates for FTI ... and $280 an hour to make copies. But, what's the big deal? Digging through and sorting out fraud is not easy. The discounts that clients can usually squeeze out of consultants and attorneys are harder to come by. So, even the 20% discount Janvey's offered doesn't amount to much